The Power of Online Reviews: How Customer Testimonials Influence Buying Decisions

Speak to one of our consultants to find out how we can support you.

Online reviews can have an incredible impact on our buying decisions because customer testimonials have completely changed the way we make our purchases. Imagine that you’re thinking about getting a new TV. What’s the first thing you do? Most of us will head straight to the internet to check out what others have to say. And that’s precisely why online reviews are so crucial. 

We’re going to explore why online reviews matter so much and why they’ve become a shopping staple for all of us. We’ll also uncover how businesses can make the most of these reviews to boost their reputation and win over new customers. Whether you’re a seasoned review reader or just starting to dip your toes into the world of customer feedback, the world of customer testimonials and the secrets behind making informed and clever buying decisions awaits.

Why online reviews matter

Think about the last time you bought something significant – maybe a phone, a pair of running shoes, or even a new fridge for your kitchen. Now, ask yourself: Did you just go with blind faith and hit that “buy now” button? No, not likely. This is where the collective wisdom of customers like you reigns supreme. These little nuggets of feedback have become an essential part of our decision-making process, and for some good reasons:

  1. The voice of the people: Companies can claim they’re the best thing since sliced bread all day long, but nothing beats hearing from real people who’ve already tried the product or service. Whether it’s a glowing testimonial or a cautionary tale, these reviews give us insights into what to expect.
  2. Trust in strangers: Okay, maybe our parents told us not to trust strangers, but in the world of online shopping, we’re making exceptions. When we see a product with dozens of positive reviews, it builds a sense of trust. 
  3. Word-of-Mouth 2.0: Remember the good old days when we’d ask friends or family for recommendations? Well, online reviews are like the upgraded version of that. We get opinions and experiences from people all over the world, 24/7. It’s like having an army of shopping friends at our fingertips.
  4. Unfiltered opinions: Unlike the shiny marketing messages we see in ads, online reviews are raw and unfiltered. People don’t hold back; they’ll tell you if something is amazing, disappointing, or just “meh.” And that honesty is worth its weight in gold.
  5. Saving hard-earned cash: None of us wants to waste our money on something that turns out to be a dud. Reviews can be a reality check, helping us avoid buyer’s remorse and directing us to products that are genuinely worth every penny.

So, whether we’re on the hunt for a new laptop, a dreamy holiday spot, or even a cosy restaurant for a special date night, online reviews are the way forward. They empower us, the consumers, and put the decision-making power right where it should be – in our hands.

Building trust through authentic customer experiences 

Building trust is the name of the game when it comes to customer testimonials, and authenticity is the golden key that unlocks that trust. This is because honesty and real experiences create genuine emotions. The last thing we want is some scripted, generic testimonial that feels like it rolled off a corporate assembly line.

So, how do businesses earn our trust through these customer experiences?

  • Keeping it real: Authenticity starts with the real deal – real customers, real stories, real emotions. When companies encourage their customers to share their unfiltered experiences, it shows that they’re not afraid of transparency. They want us to see the good, the bad, and the ugly because they know their product can stand up to scrutiny.
  • A tale of believability: Have you ever come across a review that sounds too good to be true? They can be a major red flag. Genuine testimonials have that touch of believability. They’re specific, they highlight both the pros and cons, and they give us a well-rounded picture.
  • Meet the humans behind the scenes: Putting a face to a name can work wonders. When companies share customer testimonials with photos or videos, it humanises the experience. Suddenly, it’s not just a random comment; it’s a real person with real feelings – and that provides an emotional connection.
  • Engaging with feedback: Let’s be honest; nobody’s perfect. Even the best businesses have their off days. But what sets the great ones apart is how they handle negative feedback. When we see a company engaging with customers, addressing concerns, and trying to make things right, it speaks volumes about their commitment to excellence.
  • The power of the collective: One testimonial is good, but a selection of them? Now that’s better. The power of collective opinions can’t be underestimated. When we see a stream of positive reviews, it strengthens our belief that this product or service is the real deal.

Remember, trust isn’t built overnight; it’s a journey. Companies that prioritise authentic customer experiences understand this and are willing to invest time and effort in building those long-term relationships with their customers.

The influence of ratings and review aggregators

You know those little stars you see next to products, restaurants, or services? They’re not just for decoration – they wield some serious influence over the decision-making process, and here’s why:

  1. Snap judgments – a glance is all it takes: When browsing through options online, we don’t always have the time or patience to read through every review. That’s where those star ratings come to the rescue. At a quick glance, we get an instant idea of how the masses perceive a product or service.
  2. The power of averages: Review aggregators take the wisdom of the crowd to a whole new level. They collect and crunch all those reviews, boiling them down to a tidy, average score. It’s like having a personal rating expert telling us, “Hey, this one’s a winner!”
  3. Boosting (or busting) credibility: Let’s be real – a single review might not carry much weight. But when you see that a product has thousands of reviews with a high average rating, it’s like a stamp of credibility. On the flip side, a low rating can quickly send us running in the opposite direction.
  4. Influencing perceptions: Our brains can be funny creatures. Even if we don’t consciously look at the ratings, they still manage to seep into our subconscious and influence how we perceive a product or brand. It’s like an invisible force nudging us towards certain choices.
  5. Sorting made easy: When faced with a sea of options, sorting by ratings can be a lifesaver. It helps filter out the noise and focus on the top contenders. Who has time to sift through hundreds of products anyway?

Now, here’s a little tip: While ratings and aggregators are handy, it’s essential to use them wisely. We’re all unique individuals with different needs and preferences. So, a product with a lower rating might still be the perfect fit. Also, it’s worth considering the number of reviews – a product with a single 5-star rating might not be as reliable as one with a 4.8-star rating from hundreds of customers. 

Leveraging testimonials in marketing

So you’ve got a bunch of glowing reviews from happy customers who absolutely love what you offer. Now, what’s the next step? It’s time to put them front and centre in your marketing efforts and let them work their magic.

Here are some ways to make the most of those amazing testimonials:

  • Include them on your website: Your website is like your online storefront, and what better way to build trust than by showcasing those shining testimonials right there on the homepage? Slap them on the product pages, service descriptions – or even the “Contact Us” page. Let potential customers see the love you’re getting.
  • Let social media spread the love: Social media is the ultimate cheerleader, and testimonials are the perfect content to share with your followers. Create eye-catching graphics, short video snippets, or even carousel posts featuring the best reviews. Don’t be shy to ask customers for permission to share their kind words.
  • Amp up your email campaigns: Next time you’re sending out a newsletter or promotional email, slip in a testimonial or two. It’s a fantastic way to add that human touch and give your subscribers a little extra nudge to take action.
  • Turn them into eye-catching ads: Want to attract potential customers while they’re browsing online? Use compelling quotes, eye-catching visuals, and direct them to your website for more glowing reviews.
  • Create a testimonial page: Consider dedicating a whole page on your website solely to customer testimonials. Make it easy for visitors to find and read all the amazing feedback in one go. 
  • Video testimonials – lights, camera, action: Written testimonials are fantastic, but video testimonials are next level. There’s something captivating about seeing real people talk passionately about your product or service. Get some customers on camera (with their consent, of course) and let the videos work their charm.
  • Let your customers be the voice: Instead of just putting testimonials in your marketing material, let your customers be the voice of your brand. Encourage user-generated content (UGC) featuring their experiences. Whether it’s on social media or as part of a competition, UGC can be a powerful endorsement.

Remember, testimonials aren’t just words on a screen; they’re the voice of your satisfied customers, speaking volumes about your brand’s value.

Dealing with negative reviews 

Understandably no one likes to see a less-than-glowing testimonial about their product or service. It can feel like a punch to the stomach, and our first instinct might be to ignore it or maybe even pretend it never happened. But negative reviews are not the end of the world. In fact, if handled wisely, they can be a golden opportunity for growth and improvement.

So, how do we deal with them? Here are some tips to turn those lemons into lemonade:

  1. Embrace the feedback: Take a deep breath and resist the urge to go into defence mode. Remember, negative reviews are not personal attacks. They’re valuable feedback from real customers who took the time to share their experiences. Embrace it as a chance to learn and grow.
  2. Respond with empathy: Put yourself in the customer’s shoes and respond with genuine empathy. Acknowledge their concerns and let them know you’re listening. A little bit of understanding can go a long way in diffusing tense situations.
  3. Offer solutions, not excuses: It’s essential to take responsibility and avoid making excuses. Instead, focus on finding practical solutions to address the issue. Whether it’s offering a replacement, a refund, or extra support, show that you’re committed to making things right.
  4. Take it offline: While it’s essential to respond publicly to negative reviews, it’s also a good idea to take the conversation offline. Provide a contact email or phone number so you can continue the discussion privately. This shows you’re genuinely invested in resolving the problem.
  5. Learn and improve: Negative reviews can be a reality check – they might highlight areas where your product or service needs improvement. Use this valuable feedback to identify patterns and make meaningful changes. Remember, every problem presents an opportunity to get better.
  6. Keep it professional: No matter how frustrating it may be, never engage in arguments or heated exchanges with customers. Maintain a positive tone, and rise above the negativity. Your brand’s reputation is worth more than a single review.

Remember, even the most beloved businesses receive negative reviews from time to time. It’s a natural part of being in the game. What sets exceptional companies apart is how they handle these challenges and turn them into stepping stones towards success.

The online community as our trusted advisors 

We’ve explored the vast influence of customer testimonials on buying decisions. From the psychological impact of social proof to the importance of authenticity and trust, we’ve seen how these testimonials can sway our choices in more ways than we imagined. 

The digital age has simply given us a bigger pool of information to draw from. The honest feedback and opinions of online customers provide a lifeline for making informed decisions. Plus, the help of user-generated content (UGC) for companies to use not just as a marketing tactic; but as a way to build a thriving community of customers who genuinely love what you do. To elaborate on harnessing these and other digital marketing strategies, contact us; we’re here to help.

Work with the best of the best, for less

Many businesses struggle to find high-quality support at affordable rates, slowing their growth.

Since 2015, we’ve empowered thousands of businesses to scale efficiently and optimise their operations with seamless access to a pool of quality remote talent through a flexible subscription model.

Download our free guide to find out more.

Download our Guide

By submitting this form, I consent to contact via phone and email, as per Outsourcery's Privacy Policy.

Want to join the team?
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get virtual support

Join our team

Don't leave without exploring all your options!

Let's have a no-strings-attached chat
about what you need.

By submitting this form, I consent to contact via phone and email, as per Outsourcery's Privacy Policy.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get 5 free hours with your Virtual Employee in your first month - match guarantee!